Comparing House and Share Prices

Share

Many, many people get hung up on whether houses are better than shares as long term investments and vice versa. Logic would dictate that over the long term, houses are a depreciating asset requiring substantial capital to buy or maintain with high transaction costs, and therefore are likely to underperform listed equity, which should overcome these hurdles. However, this ignores key characteristics of the property market as well as issues specific to Australia.

One issue is the availability of credit. Banks generally hold substantial residential property and so are loathe to revalue their entire portfolio down – even when market values fall. This provides an element of ‘buffer’ for borrowers and therefore additional stability for the asset class. The recent global banking crisis crimped lending in most developed countries but not in Australia. This has helped retain values. Unemployment has not suffered (proportionately) in Australia compared to the US, UK, and other developed countries. Interest rates falls have flowed directly to the average person who holds variable rate mortgages in Australia, leading to improved serviceability of existing loans and increased affordability for housing – even in the face of what are comparatively very high prices. Another issue is supply/demand, where Australian property prices reflect the distortion of a lack of available homes resulting in a difficulty in prices reaching a ‘fair market value’ – ie, a price that can be negotiated without stress by either the buyer or the seller. Supply shortages distort markets. Australia continues to enjoy historically high birthrates and sustained high levels of immigration, placing continuous pressure on the supply of housing.

Markets distort all of the time – whether in a free market or in a controlled economy – so why not just look at how the overall impact works? How about looking at an assumption of buying the “average” (remembering that averages don’t exist in residential housing) house as far back as reasonably public research will allow and assuming we take an equal amount of money and invest it into the Australian sharemarket (as reflected through the All Ordinaries Index – which has changed a bit over the years but is at least representative of the broader market).

The following chart is an attempt to do just that. Feel free to try this yourself at home. The data is available. It is made a bit more difficult by the ABS changing their measurement basis back in 2002 – but i have made a rough adjustment for that. In other words, don’t expect perfection here, folks. The idea is just to look at relativities and see if it tells us anything about these markets.

A rough look at housing and share prices

A rough look at housing and share prices

So what conclusions can you draw from this? Safely, there are none. There are so many relevant issues NOT covered that you could not safely draw very many conclusions at all. For interest sake, i have highlighted periods where it appears that the relevant values have converged. That seems reasonably logical, in that both asset classes should provide an ‘equity premium’ over risk free rates of return and you would expect that those rates would be at least vaguely similar, if you allow for the wild market swings that are possible in either property or shares. The Banking Panic of ’08 didn’t seem to impact Perth or Australian residential property prices all that much (remembering that these are ‘averages’ and there is no such thing… some individual suburbs and homes would exhibit big moves away from this average). Interestingly, these markets are now approaching their previous ‘boom’ levels. By comparison, the sharemarket appears to remain considerably below its previous high. IF it is reasonable to expec these figures to converge again in the future then there will need to either be large changes to the property or sharemarkets or a very extended period of ajustment. In the meanwhile, expect a huge amount of disagreement over just how each of these markets will perform in the future.
Share

Leave a Reply